How Do I Hire a Book Editor?

 Hiring a book editor is one of the most important investments you can make as an author. Whether you're self-publishing or aiming for a traditional publishing deal, an editor plays a critical role in refining your manuscript—shaping your raw ideas into a polished, professional, and readable book. But how do you find the right editor? How do you ensure they’re qualified? How much should you expect to pay? And what steps should you take to make the most of the editing relationship?

This comprehensive guide walks you through every stage of hiring a book editor: from preparation, research, and vetting, to collaboration, budgeting, and red flags to avoid.

---

1. Understand What Type of Editing You Need

Before you search for an editor, identify what kind of editing your manuscript requires. Editing is not a one-size-fits-all process. Each type addresses a different layer of your book:

a) Developmental Editing

Big-picture editing. Focuses on structure, plot, pacing, character arcs (for fiction), and chapter organization (for nonfiction).

b) Line Editing

Refines your prose for clarity, tone, and flow. Enhances readability and emotional impact at the sentence and paragraph level.

c) Copyediting

Checks grammar, punctuation, spelling, syntax, and consistency. Ensures technical correctness.

d) Proofreading

Final polish before publishing. Catches typos, formatting issues, and small grammar errors.

Tip: If you’re early in your manuscript journey, consider starting with developmental editing. If your structure is sound and you’ve revised heavily, copyediting or line editing may be the next step.

---

2. Prepare Your Manuscript for Editing

Before reaching out to editors:

• Finish your draft. Editors work best with a complete manuscript.

• Do a self-edit. Clean up obvious errors, cut redundancies, and clarify your writing.

• Know your word count. Editors typically price based on this.

• Identify your genre and target audience. This helps you find editors with relevant experience.

You’ll save time and money if your manuscript is as clean as possible before hiring a professional.

---

3. Set Your Editing Budget

Editing costs vary based on manuscript length, type of editing, editor experience, and turnaround time.

Typical ranges for a 70,000-word book (USD):

• Developmental Editing: $2,100 – $5,600

• Line Editing: $1,400 – $3,500

• Copyediting: $700 – $2,100

• Proofreading: $350 – $1,050

Tip: Budget 20–30% of your publishing costs for editing. It’s a professional service, not an optional luxury.

---

4. Start Searching for Editors

A) Professional Marketplaces

• Reedsy – Vetted editors with publishing experience. Ideal for finding high-quality professionals.

• Editorial Freelancers Association (EFA) – U.S.-based network of editors with posted rates.

• ACES (The Society for Editing) – Directory of certified editors.

B) Freelance Platforms

• Upwork – Great variety; filter by reviews and experience.

• Fiverr – Lower-cost, but be cautious and ask for samples.

• PeoplePerHour / Freelancer.com – Global options with flexible pricing.

C) Writing Communities

• Facebook author groups

• Subreddits like r/selfpublish or r/writing

• NaNoWriMo forums

• Author coaching communities

Ask for referrals from fellow writers—they're often your best source for trusted editors.

---

5. Vet Your Potential Editors Carefully

Once you find candidates, research and evaluate each one.

Check for:

• Experience in your genre

• Portfolio or past client work

• Testimonials and reviews

• Relevant education or credentials

• Turnaround time and availability

Ask for a sample edit (usually 1,000–2,000 words). This helps you assess the editor’s style, attention to detail, and communication approach.

Good questions to ask editors:

• What’s your editing process?

• How do you deliver feedback?

• Do you use a style guide (e.g., Chicago Manual of Style)?

• What’s your experience in this genre?

• What’s your average turnaround time?

• What are your rates, and how are they structured?

---

6. Compare Quotes and Scope of Services

Editors price their services based on:

• Per word (e.g., $0.02/word)

• Per hour (e.g., $30–$75/hr)

• Per project (flat fee)

Compare:

• What's included in the price (track changes, summary notes, style sheet)?

• Number of editing rounds

• Revisions or feedback support

• Payment terms (upfront, 50/50, on delivery)

Tip: Don’t choose the cheapest option. Choose the most qualified editor whose communication, professionalism, and style match your needs.

---

7. Sign a Clear Agreement

Once you’ve chosen your editor, make the relationship official with a written contract.

The agreement should cover:

• Scope of work (type of editing, word count, services)

• Delivery timeline

• Payment terms and total cost

• Revision or follow-up policy

• Confidentiality clause

• Cancellation or refund policy

Avoid vague or verbal agreements—this protects both you and the editor.

---

8. Collaborate and Communicate During the Process

The editing process is a partnership. Stay engaged, flexible, and open to feedback.

While working with an editor:

• Respond promptly to messages or questions

• Ask for clarification when needed

• Respect their expertise—but don’t hesitate to explain your vision

• Allow time for revisions without rushing

You’ll typically receive your manuscript with track changes enabled, comments in the margins, and sometimes a summary letter with high-level observations.

---

9. Review the Edits Thoughtfully

When you get your manuscript back:

• Read all the notes and suggestions

• Go through each edit carefully

• Accept or reject changes one by one

• Ask follow-up questions if needed

Don’t blindly accept every edit—but do take time to understand the editor’s reasoning. Good editors respect your voice while improving your work.

---

10. When to Consider a Second Edit

Depending on your goals and budget, you may want:

• A second round of line editing after big developmental changes

• Copyediting after developmental edits

• Proofreading after final layout formatting

You don’t need all types of editing at once. You can hire in stages as your manuscript evolves.

---

11. Red Flags to Avoid

Not every editor is qualified or trustworthy. Watch out for:

• No sample edit or vague responses

• Unrealistically fast turnaround (e.g., full novel edited in 24 hours)

• No contract or formal agreement

• Inexperience in your genre

• Lack of testimonials or online presence

• Poor grammar/spelling in their own communication

Trust your gut. If something feels off, keep looking.

---

12. Alternatives If You’re On a Tight Budget

If you can't afford a professional editor yet:

• Beta readers: Free feedback from real readers

• Writing groups: Exchange critiques with other authors

• Editing software: Use tools like ProWritingAid or Grammarly to polish before hiring an editor

• Hire per chapter or in sections

• Barter skills: Offer your design, tech, or writing help in exchange

Even on a budget, aim for at least one professional editing pass before publishing.

---

Conclusion

Hiring a book editor is not just about fixing mistakes—it’s about elevating your manuscript to its highest potential. A skilled editor brings clarity, structure, and professionalism to your work, helping you create a book that readers will enjoy and remember.

Take time to:

• Understand your editing needs

• Prepare your manuscript

• Research editors thoroughly

• Get samples and compare offers

• Sign a clear agreement

• Stay engaged in the editing process

A good editor won’t just improve your current book—they’ll help you become a stronger writer for future projects. Make the right hire, and you’ll be one giant step closer to publishing a book you can be proud of.