Was the Business Started Before or After the Marriage, and How Does This Affect Its Ownership During a Divorce?

 When navigating the complexities of a divorce, especially when business ownership is involved, one crucial factor that comes into play is whether the business was started before or after the marriage. This simple but critical detail can heavily influence how the business is treated during the divorce process. Understanding the distinction between these two scenarios is essential, as it determines whether the business will be considered part of the marital estate and how ownership will be divided.

In this post, we’ll explore how the timing of the business’s establishment impacts ownership during a divorce, and what factors come into play when dividing a business that was either started before or after the marriage.

A Business Started Before the Marriage: Separate or Marital Property?

When a business is started before the marriage, it is generally treated as separate property. Separate property refers to assets that belong solely to one spouse, and as long as no marital funds or efforts contributed to its growth, the business would remain the separate property of the spouse who founded it. However, things aren’t always as simple as they seem, especially when it comes to the impact of a divorce.

How It Works:

Let’s say you started a business before getting married, and that business has been your sole responsibility and source of income. In a divorce, if no marital funds were used to run or grow the business, it’s likely that the business will be classified as separate property, meaning your spouse may not have a claim to it.

But, and this is important, if the business has grown substantially during the course of the marriage, there could be some complicated considerations. For example, let’s say you started the business with an initial investment from personal savings, but over the years, marital income was used to expand the business, hire employees, or make significant improvements. In this case, the business could be partially considered marital property because the marital estate has contributed to its growth.

This is where things can get tricky. Even though the business was founded before the marriage, if your spouse contributed in any significant way—whether financially or by taking care of household matters, providing emotional support, or performing tasks that helped the business grow—the court may decide that your spouse is entitled to a portion of the value of the business.

What Happens Next?

If a business that was started before the marriage has increased in value due to marital contributions, the court will typically assess how much of that value is attributable to efforts made during the marriage. The business could then be divided accordingly, with a portion considered separate property and the remaining portion as marital property.

For instance, the growth in value—such as the increase in customers, revenue, or assets—could be shared with the non-owner spouse, depending on the jurisdiction’s laws. This is commonly referred to as the active appreciation of the business, and if the non-owner spouse can demonstrate a contribution, they may be entitled to a share.

---

A Business Started After the Marriage: Clearly Marital Property

When a business is started during the marriage, it is almost always classified as marital property. Marital property is any asset that was acquired during the marriage, regardless of who holds the legal title or who did the work. This means that any business created after the marriage, even if one spouse is the sole founder, is generally subject to division during the divorce.

How It Works:

Let’s say you and your spouse get married, and shortly after, you start a business together. Since the business was formed during the marriage, it will likely be treated as a marital asset. In most jurisdictions, the value of the business will be divided equitably (not necessarily equally) between the two spouses.

It doesn’t matter whether one spouse was the primary operator of the business or if only one spouse held ownership; the business’s value is still considered to be part of the marital estate, and both parties typically have a right to a share. This applies whether the business is a sole proprietorship, a partnership, or an LLC.

What Happens Next?

During the divorce, the business will be assessed for its current value. If the business has grown significantly, both spouses may be entitled to a share of the increase in value, regardless of who ran the business. It’s common for one spouse to buy out the other’s share if they want to maintain full ownership. Alternatively, the court may order the business to be sold and the proceeds divided between the spouses.

If one spouse was more involved in the daily operations and management of the business, that may be considered when dividing assets. But just because one spouse was less involved doesn’t mean they won’t have a claim to the business’s value. If the other spouse contributed in some way—whether by helping with household chores, taking care of children, or financially supporting the business—it could still result in a claim for a portion of the business.

---

What Happens If There’s a Hybrid Situation: A Business Started Before the Marriage but Expanded During?

In some cases, the business may have been founded before the marriage but saw considerable growth during the marriage due to contributions made by both spouses. This is what we might call a hybrid business, where part of it is considered separate property, and part of it is considered marital property.

How It Works:

The court will typically look at two factors:

1. The value of the business at the time of marriage: The business may have had a set value when you and your spouse married, and that portion will likely remain separate property.

2. The increase in value during the marriage: If the business’s value increased after the marriage, it could be considered marital property if the increase was due to the spouse’s efforts or the use of marital funds.

For example, if you started a software development company before the marriage, but over the course of the marriage, your spouse took on a significant role in customer relations, marketing, or expanding the product line, the business’s growth could be considered active appreciation and thus entitled to be split as part of the marital estate.

This hybrid approach can make things more complicated. The business will likely be valued as a whole, with an effort made to distinguish between the portions of the business that were built before the marriage and those that were developed afterward. Expert witnesses, such as business valuators, are often called upon to assess the value and determine the percentage of growth attributable to the marriage.

---

Conclusion: Timing Matters in Business Ownership Division During Divorce

To summarize, whether a business was started before or after the marriage plays a key role in determining its division during a divorce.

• Before the marriage: The business is typically considered separate property unless marital funds or efforts were involved in its growth.

• During the marriage: The business is generally treated as a marital asset and is subject to equitable division.

• Hybrid situations: If the business was started before but grew during the marriage, a complex evaluation will determine the percentage of the business considered separate versus marital property.

It’s important for both spouses to fully understand the nuances of business ownership and marital property law to ensure they’re fairly represented during the division process. If you’re involved in a divorce and a business is at stake, seeking the guidance of a legal professional, as well as a business valuation expert, can help clarify how your business will be treated and what steps you can take to protect your interests.